Oh well...

These are musings on sundry matters, some personal and some of general interest to me. It will be nice to have comments from those of you who actually read this stuff. And more often than not, I will comment on your comments as well. So check back. And please, don't leave any damn links instead of comments.

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

One for the Devanagari readers

Before I set out to do this, I think I should clarify a bit. I have more time on my hands than I would like, or even know what to do with. So I thought I will give this a shot, at least with a short post. Of course, I did not want to do this at the expense of cutting down the number of my readers (not that there are too many anyway). So for those for whom the script below might as well be Martian, scroll down a bit, and you will find a translation that you will follow. Now that I have explained...

तो मैं सोच रहा था कि क्या लिखा जाये? अगर हिन्दी में लिख रहा हूँ तो क्यों न अपने देसी भाई-बंधुओं के बारे में लिखूं? लेकिन मेरे दिमाग के गधे प्रवासी नागरिकों की ओर दौड़ रहे हैं। तो वही सही।

मेरी जान-पहचान के जो भारतीय इस शहर में रहते हैं, उनको मोटा-मोटी २ भान्तियों में बांटा जा सकता है। पहली भाँती वह जिनको अपनी मात्र्भूमि से कोई खास लगाव नहीं है, बल्कि उनको बहुत प्रसन्नता है कि वो किसी developed देश में हैं जहाँ औरतों की चमड़ी गोरी है। ऐसे लोगों के बोलने का लहजा बदलते कोई समय नहीं लगता, हवाई-जहाज़ से उतरते ही अचानक उन्हें "fake accent" नामक बिमारी हो जाती है। (लेकिन कुछ ऐसे भी होते हैं जिनको यह बिमारी दिल्ली या मुम्बई हवाई अड्डे पर हवाई-जहाज़ में बैठने के साथ ही लग जाती है!) यह पहली भाँती के लोग ऐसी भी कोशिश करते हैं कि इनके मित्रगण में अन्य भारतीय कम से कम हों। मेरे ख्याल से ऐसा करने से उनको एक तरह की "truly international feeling" महसूस होती है, जिससे उनके अपने छोटे से ब्रह्माण्ड में ख़ुशी कि १-२ लहरें दौड़ जाती हैं। अगर उनको ऐसी छोटी निक्कार हरकतों से ही ख़ुशी मिलती है तो मैं या तुम कौन हैं उसे रोकने वाले? हाँ, अगर तुम्हारा इरादा उनको चूतीया बुला कर उन पर हंसने का है तो मैं तुम्हारे साथ हूँ।

अब दूसरी भाँती। यह उन लोगों की है जो अपने देश से दूर जा कर उसके और भी करीब हो जाते हैं। अंग्रेजी में एक कहावत है, "distance makes the heart grow fonder"। मैं इस कहावत में विश्वास नहीं करता लेकिन ऐसे लोगों से मिलना मुझे दुविधा में डाल देता है। शारीरिक और मानसिक दूरियों के बीच का उल्टा संबंध मुझे कुछ समझ में नहीं आया। जब वो भारत में थे, तब वो सामान्य थे। लेकिन अब, जब वो भारत में नहीं हैं, अचानक भारत देश महान और जय गंगा मईये। भिन्न भिन्न प्रकार के लोगों के बीच में जब अपना खुद का दिमाग काम नहीं करे तो अपनी देश की आन को बीच में ले आओ। पहले अपने देश को जितनी गाली देते थे, अब उसके उतने ही गुण गाओ. मेरे ख्याल से काफी कट्टरवादी ऐसे ही बनते हैं।

मैं अभी तक इस निर्णय पर नहीं पहुंच पाया हूँ कि ज्यादा चूतीये कौन हैं, पहली या दूसरी भाँती? आप की क्या राय है?

Alright, I have to say I have impressed myself a bit with all this Hindi. Small pat on the back. Without ado, here is the translation (which I will try keep as literal as possible):

So I was thinking what to write? If writing in Hindi, why not write about my desi brothers and friends? But my mind's asses run in the direction of diasporic citizens. So be it.

The Indians living in this city that I know can be more or less divided into 2 kinds. The first kind is those that have no special attachment to their motherland, in fact they are happy to be in a developed country where the women have white skin. It takes no time for such peoples' speech to change, they acquire a disease called "fake accent" the moment they step off the aeroplane. (But there are also those who get diseased the moment they sit in to the aeroplane at the Delhi or Mumbai airports!) These people of the first kind also make efforts such that in their circle of friends, there are as few Indians as possible. I think doing this makes them feel a sort of "truly international feeling", which causes 1-2 waves of happiness to flow through their small universe. If they derive happiness from such small useless actions, who are you or me to stop them? Of course, if your intent is to call them a moron (the word 'moron' does little justice to चूतीया, which would literally mean closer to 'fucker' but that is not the implication I seek here-in)and laugh at them, then I am with you.

Now the second kind. It is of those people who go far from their country to get even closer to it. There is a saying in English, "distance makes the heart grow fonder". I have never believed in this saying but meeting such people puts me in a conundrum. I do not quite follow the inverse relationship between physical and mental distances. When they were in India, they were normal. But now, that they are not in India, suddenly India is a great country and Praise Mother Ganges. When the mind doesn't work amid a group of people of many many different kinds, drag the honour of the country in between. Earlier, the extent to which they called their country names, now, sing as many praises to it. I think this is what leads to the formation of extremists.

I still have not been able to decide who is more moronic (चूतीया once again), the first or the second kind? What is your opinion?

12 comments:

Anonymous said...

interesting that you chose to leave second/third generations out himanshu. i think its a huge oversight...especially if you're talking about all of the indians you meet in london and if you're talking about diasporic citizens.

the connection between identity and 'homeland' is more personal and complicated than you're making it out to be. 'faking accents' are conscious decisions that have more roots than a simple denial of skin or culture.

that being said. i think anyone that thinks losing their accent makes them more 'international' is an idiot. more than the person who's become the 'fundamentalist'.

but i cant end with that opinion, cause honestly himanshu, i think you're wrong. not only about the 'two kinds', but because you are trying to make judgements without understanding motivation. and when you're talking about identity - how can you freeze someone in time like that? isnt it identification - a process which implies constant change and movement? (yes that's straight out of S. Hall)

you and i were always meant to disagree, i think. anita xxx

The Author said...

err... i am referring of only 1st generation folks, and folks of my generation or age group at that. and its my choice to do that. i am not dividing them in to two kinds alone, else, where would i fit? i am also not probing into causalities but merely looking at a particular slice of time, which again, is my prerogative.

maybe we are meant to disagree, but when i am talking apples, don't talk meat!

Anonymous said...

perogatives aside, isnt it causality that is the real 'meat' of the issue?
why bother describing a static moment, when the beginning is what's important?
(and that's not rhetorical, i am sincerely asking that)

of course, if we are talking about perogatives, i cant help but remind you of this: "The Indians living in this city that I know can be more or less divided into 2 kinds." 'err' is right.

The Author said...

anon #2, i am sure i missed the joke on me in your comment. your humour knows no bounds. as for the answer to your sincere question, i shall once again be forced to answer that in my next post since this comments section need to be unduly lengthened.

Unknown said...

Kassi asabhya shabdon ka pryog karte ho... ram ram. and chutiya is so much more offensive than moronic , no?

anyhow, i totally understand the different kinds that you are talking about. also, don't know if you've ever come across such cases where a chap has an entirely indian accent (well, not too deep but just like how we normally speak amongst us) but has a irish tone of speaking, if you know what i mean.

But i suppose you miss out on those Indians who stay away from other Indians abroad just coz they are away from home and would like to experience an entirely different culture and be with 'other' people. This syndrome is pretty genuine and not just faking an international feeling. And this is seen among many other nationalities! perhaps most militantly demonstarted amongst the Germans.

and of course, you also miss out on those who neither disown their Indian-ness nor embrace it conservatively.

Everyone misses home.. some more than others. For home is where you know how things work, how things are and a cultural understanding that eases existence. However, experiencing and assimilating in a new culture is an interesting and challenging job in itself. again, some cherish it while others resent it.

The Author said...

raghu, you are bang on target about the offensive language. some people are so insensitive, right? i know i left out categories (such as the one you or me would fall in), but i wasn't trying to be comprehensive, but merely trying to lampoon. and keep in mind that it was originally written in hindi, so there was only so much i could write at a go!

Anonymous said...

you missed out so many categories - those who stil love india but choose to stay here for various other reasons (maybe the money is good? maybe for a different experience?), those who hate india and were looking to get out anyway (no matter what?), those who came here for a flaky reason which seemed completely silly at the outset (but maybe it transfomed into something deeper, more meaningful?)..very convenient how u managed to divide everyone else into 2 types (and of course 2 seemingly inferior varities or chutiyas) and kept yourself above and out of this division..
you were right himanshu..you are a bastard..and it's unbelievable how damn hypocritical u r and really sad that u dont even realise it..u are part of the very phenomenon u frown upon and that makes u pathetic..

The Author said...

hahaha. whichever idiot wrote the last comment... did you not read the bit where i said "most of the Indians in this city that I know"? and if you did read it, which part of it did you not follow, you nitwit? or perhaps you didn't bother to read the comments section where you posted your own stale opinion which i have already countered. and for your own sake, go get a sense of humour from somewhere if you can't develop one of your own.

Anonymous said...

hahaha this is so much fun...i think i will watch ur blog closely now...

-from the humour-less nitwit

The Author said...

no shit sherlock

Anonymous said...

hahaha isn't sarcasm the lowest form of wit? i expected better from you hahaha

The Author said...

just in case you didn't know, i am not exactly trying or hoping to meet your expectations. and no, i do not share your belief about sarcasm as a low form of wit. also, i wasn't trying to be witty, merely factual. all the same, whatever turns you on man...